The problem with door-to-door fundraising

Dayton, Ohio -- Many non-profits have had success with door-to-door fundraising programs, such as selling candy or other items. There are benefits of such programs but also a significant downside.

When someone comes to my door asking for a donation or selling an item for a non-profit, I have one of two reactions.

(1) If I don't know the person, I usually don't give. I find it intrusive to learn about a non-profit's cause for the first time from someone standing at my door. (If I've given to the non-profit before and the person acknowledges it, my attitude is different.)

(2) If I know the person (e.g., a neighborhood kid), I usually give but not because I believe in the cause. I give to support the person I know. That makes it extremely unlikely I will give again if solicited by mail. Many times, I can't even remember the organization (was it the Boy Scouts or the school athletic team?)

That's why the neighborhood kid can convince you to make a donation without ever telling you much about the cause for which the money is being raised. How many times has the first line been, "I'm selling popcorn for $10 a tin." (What would happen if a direct mail solicitation lead with "we want you to make a $50 gift?") But it doesn't matter as much when you know the person asking for the gift.

So door-to-door fundraising may raise some money but don't expect it to create life-long donors. The only way to get a second gift is to have the same person knock on those same doors again next year.